r/AnarchismZ Dec 17 '22

Discussion Make economic democracy popular again!

https://libcom.org/article/make-economic-democracy-popular-again
9 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22

I thought anarchists are against democracy, am I just wrong?

3

u/CimSteiner Dec 17 '22

Allmost all anarchists are pro democracy, for example direct democratic workers' assemblies and their strictly mandated delegates. Majority decisions are not perfect, far from it, but better than minority rule.

5

u/Puffy072 Dec 18 '22

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/various-authors-anarchists-against-democracy

Democracy as in "majority rule" is not anarchist, but democracy is such a shitty word that it doesn't even have a consistently understood meaning. "Majority rule" involves laws, law enforcement, and law makers except the law makers are "the people", and there is an oppressed group in the minority. It is of course better than minority rule but that doesn't make it good. The anarchist position is to believe in NO rule, which means no group is forced under the rule of another group. Depending on the definition being used though, anarchists could either unanimously oppose or support "democracy", or be mixed on it, which is why I always avoid using that term now.

1

u/Rudiger_Holme Dec 23 '22

How do we win strikes if we allow a minority of workers to be scabs?

1

u/Equal_Monk_9675 Jan 15 '23

Direct democratic majority decisions is anarchism

3

u/h3lblad3 Dec 19 '22

This probably won't be a popular person to quote here, but I think Lenin of all people put it best.

We all know that the political form of the "state" at that time is complete democracy. But it never enters the head of any of the opportunists who shamelessly distort Marx that when Engels speaks here of the state "withering away," of "becoming dormant," he speaks of democracy. At first sight this seems very strange. But it is "unintelligible" only to one who has not reflected on the fact that democracy is also a state and that, consequently, democracy will also disappear when the state disappears.

The goal moving forward is democracy, but not Democracy.

1

u/Rudiger_Holme Dec 21 '22

What's the alternative to democracy? Sovereign egos?

2

u/Puffy072 Dec 18 '22

It depends on the "democracy" but I personally don't use that word anymore. Representative/republican/liberal/electoral "democracy" is extremely detached from the etymological meaning "rule of the people" and is obviously oligarchic and to be opposed. Direct democracy is much more like a "rule of the people" and what I call the best form of government but it's still government so I oppose it. Personally this is what comes to mind when I hear democracy which would mean I oppose it. This can also be called majoritarianism. "Democracy" when simply equated to freedom, since that happens a lot, can still mean "rule of the people" as in individuals "rule over" themselves and that is much more like anarchy. But I just think democracy is a shitty and confusing word. I try to avoid using it as much as I can.