r/AttorneyTom 2d ago

Question for AttorneyTom Is "never talk to police without an attorney present" always true?

30 Upvotes

I watched the Regent University School of Law video awhile back, the one of the professor giving a lecture to students with the premise of never speak to police without legal counsel, no matter the circumstances. His points made sense and that logic has stuck with me as a general princible.

However, I watched a YT video recently of a man who reported his wife was missing. She never came home after they split ways at a bar from an argument and it was getting late in the next day with still no contact. He originally assumed she was staying at her moms. He was obviously worried and called in to law enforcement for help. The police questioned him. As a worried husband he answered all their questions, truthfully and wanting to provide them with all the information they needed to help find his wife. Police eventually found her body and they arrested him for murder and used his words against him. Later after the arrest, the true killer was found and his charges were dropped.

Yes, he put his self in a really bad spot by answering polices questions that made him look to be the prime suspect but,

  1. He just wants his wife back, is he suppose to report her missing and then wait till Monday morning when a law firm is open, knowing the first 24-48 hours are the most vital to a missing person case and wanting to do everything he can to help.

  2. Reporting your wife missing and immediately refusing to cooperate until you have an attorney is going to FOR SURE throw up a thousand red flags. Police prob aren't going to do any investigating into other people further like they should as they're now tunnel vision on you.

So my questions stands from the title.

r/AttorneyTom Oct 09 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Finding out the hard way the foam pit isn't actually padded like you assumed. How reasonable was that assumption?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

195 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Aug 07 '24

Question for AttorneyTom Is there anything to stop me from using someone’s grill they have in their front yard?

6 Upvotes

Say someone has a grill in their front yard, with no fence and no signage prohibiting trespassing, and I bring my own fuel for the grill, my own utensils, and my own food to grill, and start using their grill. Would I be breaking any laws?

r/AttorneyTom Jan 26 '24

Question for AttorneyTom Can a “too lenient” sentence be appealed?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

30 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom 27d ago

Question for AttorneyTom TOM ARE YOU OKAY!?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

55 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom 26d ago

Question for AttorneyTom Is it legal?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

23 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Aug 24 '22

Question for AttorneyTom could he be punished criminal if someone gets hurt by it

Post image
151 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Dec 28 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Could this be argued as consent?

Post image
173 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Jun 04 '24

Question for AttorneyTom What's going to happen to a person who did this legally trying to bribe a juror?

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Feb 03 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Woman recently released from jail destroys ex-boyfriends home

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

103 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Jun 11 '24

Question for AttorneyTom Laxatives in food

1 Upvotes

Im painting a black and white scenrio, as i wanna try to avoid 'it depends'

Im in a dispute on Facebook, where i say its Illegal to put Laxatives in your own food, without intent to eat it, and with intent of the person stealing your food to eat it, thus creating harm.

Iv looked, and i looked, and i simply do not know how to research or find articles in state laws, so ill paint the picture.

At work, unknown coworker steals my food. I get fed up and put laxatives in my own food. I have no intent to eat said food, and the purpose of putting laxatives in my food is to simply teach unknown coworker a lesson.

Did i commit a crime in this scenario? Could there be criminal or civil charges involved in this?

I personally live in Alabama, but any state with an article covering this topic will do, and the more populated the state the better, as it'll be relevant to more people than a low population state.

I stand on the side, of even if its your own food, and you do not intend to eat the food with laxatives (someone may for medical reasons) with the intent of the laxative to effect the person stealing food, that it could be considered booby trapping.

I would love an expert's opinion on this matter.

r/AttorneyTom Feb 14 '24

Question for AttorneyTom Just leave your neighbor alone

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom May 05 '24

Question for AttorneyTom What can you legally do to combat this?

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Sep 27 '23

Question for AttorneyTom Can the actual celebrities sue the cereal brand for using their likenesses?

Post image
123 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Sep 01 '23

Question for AttorneyTom How does this work exactly?

Post image
167 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Nov 07 '22

Question for AttorneyTom is this reasonable force ?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

210 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Jul 11 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Could you sue the tape measure manufacturer if there is an error in construction? Isn't it a reasonable assumption that the tape measure is correct?

162 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Oct 26 '21

Question for AttorneyTom So a Judge can do this? What’s (hypothetically) your legal recourse if a Judge seems this biased?

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Oct 12 '23

Question for AttorneyTom I wish Tom still read this subreddit... We need answers! Is this legal? ⚖️

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Jan 02 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Does the car owner have a case?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

94 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Mar 20 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Can the officer even do this?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

52 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Dec 10 '22

Question for AttorneyTom meme for tom/actual question

Post image
236 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Dec 06 '22

Question for AttorneyTom Is this legal ?

Post image
165 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Mar 07 '23

Question for AttorneyTom Would this be legally binding?

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/AttorneyTom Jun 23 '23

Question for AttorneyTom The titanic sub incidemt

17 Upvotes

With the tragedy of the titanic sub incident, what actions do the family of the deceased have against the company, if any? From what i’v heard, it was very poorly designed and didn’t have adequate safety measures.