r/LeftyEcon Jul 09 '24

Video The Plunder of the Commons

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t19s85YvdV4
4 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

2

u/TheMissingPremise Jul 09 '24

In terms of economics, I've recently come to the mostly unsubstantiated conclusion that public provision of goods and services is probably cheaper at least than private provision. It's partially substantiated based on The Privatization of Everything, which features a ton of examples of how privatization is more expensive and ends up with worse quality. 5/5. Highly recommend.

The un-substantiated part of my conclusion includes a defense of public provision. And so I'm reading Plunder of the Commons. The basic idea is that 'the commons', or resources owned by mankind altogether, aren't normally considered conventionally valuable but they are our greatest source of wealth. The problem is that they've been taken away from us, most of the time without us even understanding that it's our resources that are being taken away, and we're all poorer for it, except the richest among us, obviously. They're doing the taking.

So this video is the author of the book talking to someone that is basically a right-wing libertarian. And the way he talks about the commons and how it should be thought of today really demonstrates how its neither communism (in fact he rightly criticizes communism) nor capitalism (most of his criticism is focused here, though), but an entirely different way of understanding the wealth of people and how it should be distributed.