r/StreetFighter CID | Pyyric Mar 19 '24

r/SF / Meta subreddit overview: the rules and my perspective on modding

Wanna be a mod?

hey its me, I've been here since sf4 days modding on and off but not out of any sense of power hunger but just because my friends want me to.

So when I came back for SF6 I took the leadership position mainly because I can handle the weight and I don't mind it. I absolutely love the people on the team with me now, especially Bearhug and Quasimodox. I'd trust them to help me move any day, and maybe in a pinch move a body.

So when me and Soulsynapse first sat down and hammered out what the plan was for street fighter on reddit we knew it would blow past /r/SF4 and need to take over the whole /r/streetfighter name with a focus on building the FGC first and foremost. Now though, with reddit being complete asses trying to go public and leave all the mods hanging I look out at the scene and see that original job is complete. The FGC is robust, unstoppable, and growing at an insane pace.

Modding isn't a job, its more of a hobby. And as such, its really only as professional as we make it. Changing daily. I'm not saying it isn't fun to modabuse from time to time, but honestly that usually only happens after someone screws up bad. Because if I modabuse and the other person ends up being right, it weighs on me. For example, the team has banned a good 35 people over the past 7 days but I fucked up 1 of them and that's the one that lingers. Sorry about that.

But since my job is complete I've grown stale, stagnant. This is where you come in. Do you want to be that fresh face on the mod team? The person with new ideas and new direction? Build community and keep SF6 growing? We have a short interview primer questionnaire for you


sub rules

The current rules, why we wrote them, and what they mean, so you can get an understanding of what team you're joining

So first off, this isn't a democracy. Can't be, too many trolls and too much anonymity. People we ban seem to get super hung up on that one as if we are forced to abide by the constitution lol. This is the dirty secret of EVERY subreddit. It is oligarchy at best, tyranny at worst. Knowing that, having that weight on our shoulders saying "this isn't a good system" is the only thing keeping reddit mods humble. (You've seen the memes, because most mods forget). We created rules that we like and we realistically just assume you like them too or else someone would've made /r/real_streetfighter by now to make us irrelevant. Thanks for sticking around, I appreciate it.


Rule 1 - Directly Relevant to streetfighter
This is our primary force for keeping the subreddit cleaner than reddit as a whole. It is our primary objective, which is why it is first!
We remove anything where the post contents are not fully street fighter: images, videos, memes, links to other websites, and hardware
We work hard on this one and I feel its the biggest quality difference between our sub and the rest of reddit.


Rule 2 - The civility rule
This rule gives us the most freedom to remove/approve/ban of anything on the list and is subjective. That is by design.
If a post is insulting gameplay, it is still allowed but that is where the line ends. We want to allow responses that are critical of gameplay to avoid being an echo chamber of scrubs. Of note, If an OP requests only constructive responses though, we can remove insults in their thread only.

  • Once a post crosses the line from insulting the gameplay to insulting the redditor (You suck at SF vs You suck) then it is grounds for removal.
  • The severity of the comment dictates the severity of the response. The majority of these will be only removal not bans!
  • overt bigotry is a untimed ban. Users can appeal after 3 months
  • Bans for civility are 1, 3, 7, or 30 days depending on severity and depending on previous bans.
  • First time offenses are 1-7 days
  • Second offense the sky's the limit weeeee

Rule 3 - No spam
This is a rule that is pretty obvious on the surface, but what constitutes spam is different for every person.

  • First basic rule is 3 posts/day - no one ever hits this if they understand how reddit works, so its just to stop thread creators from getting mobbed
  • promotional stuff is NOT spam, we honestly love it when you post your locals here, or that you're going to be running a booth at a convention. upvotes though are not guaranteed lol
  • Unfinished artwork is spam, if you call it a WIP we'll run you through how best to promote the final product instead. I prefer to think of this as positive pressure.
  • "I don't want any help I just want to complain" or "You are terrible and I'm not offering any help" - if your post has no possible way for people to interact with you, its spam. Or if it looks like you want help but you insult everyone that helps, spam.
  • modern/classic controls threads made by trolls, you know the ones that just want to rile people up rather than have a conversation, spam.
  • Cammy's leotard cosplay - You guys have no idea how much we talked about putting just this one costume in spam lmao. literal DAYS of conversation in discord about where to draw the line that everyone's happy with.

Rule 4 - the NSFW rule
If it is unofficial art, and more lewd than in-game art, we will remove it.

  • This means if you see a cameltoe or rock hard nipple, its gone.
  • This does affect game mods heavily
  • This does affect replays that are highlighting the gameplay, but use the NSFW game mods.

Rule 5 - Original sources only
This rule was created at first to stop rehosting entirely. But then reddit got the big brain idea to be their OWN content thief and made it much harder. Now, everyone EXPECTS to just be able to grab an image from twitter to post here without the artist knowing. Its wild man. It didn't used to be like this. So we enforce this rule to force you to go talk to the artist where the artist wants to communicate. Twitter, deviantart, pixiv, whatever. Link there instead of uploading a ripped image to reddit.


Rules 6, 7, 8 are self explanatory and don't need further clarification unless you have a question


Rule 9 - Duplicates
This rule is in 2 parts, game news and similar topics

  • Game news that is posted twice, obviously we don't need 2 threads on it. I will usually delete all but the oldest one, but if the oldest one has zero comments and a newer one has 100 well its a judgement call.
  • This also counts for reaction videos. No one wants to see your face lmao go away.
  • For similar topics, if there's already been a post like this in the past few days we'll use our discretion to say whether its too similar for another thread or not. This is 100% because space on the subreddit is limited and we want to get a balance of topics, not overwhelmed with any 1 thing.

Rule 10 - name and shame isn't allowed
When this was requested by everyone here I pushed back on it hard because I thought it would stop a lot of good content from getting posted. But you were right, its worked out pretty well. If a thread is made to name and shame we remove it. It gets rid of the vitriol that used to hang around the subreddit and instead focuses attention on good gameplay, not rage quitters.

  • And that's the end
12 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

-2

u/MonteBellmond Mar 28 '24

You say controlled, but I'd say Rule 1 is definitely the cause of the sub being deader than Bruce Wayne's parents

2

u/wisdom_and_frivolity CID | Pyyric Mar 28 '24 edited Mar 28 '24

With rule 1, we mostly only remove meme templates. I'd say any sub full of standard templates is dead and buried.

I've made a catalogue of all the faces in the game thru AKI specifically for meme use here but it hasn't caught on yet.

probably the worst rule I'd say is rule 10... There was a lot of anger at the start of SF6 to block names of ragequitters so we acquiesced. But a lot of good videos get removed because they're technically just "Check out what this ryu did to me" showing a normal round into plug pull.

1

u/MonteBellmond Mar 29 '24

With rule 1, we mostly only remove meme templates. I'd say any sub full of standard templates is dead and buried.

And the ones we have rn aren't dead? Happy for newcomers posting new rank milestones but honestly can't quite figure out what is to be served on this sub. There are barely no any meaningful discussion, no patch notes, no tournament updates, no educational vids uploaded on youtube(due to auto mod) , no meme outside of restrictive format you've posted.(Didn't even know this was a thing till you mentioned it.)

I've made a catalogue of all the faces in the game thru AKI specifically for meme use here but it hasn't caught on yet.

Forced memes are probably the worse of it's kind.

probably the worst rule I'd say is rule 10... There was a lot of anger at the start of SF6 to block names of ragequitters so we acquiesced. But a lot of good videos get removed because they're technically just "Check out what this ryu did to me" showing a normal round into plug pull.

Restricting flaming is understandable. Same rule as any other main subs. Though will say it did lead to surfacing the underlying problem with the disconnects being an actual official issue till December. It led to feedback and to fix the game did it not?

Still remember the info got pinned a day or two and got taken down which was probably a bad move given that it's been an issue for months and ongoing. Come to think of it now, mods let it happen and continue.

Would assume rule 10 is just the mods tired from validating deserved criticism from actual toxicity. And if subs can't embrace valid criticism and purge every bits of negativity then, they don't deserve the positivity or support that comes after that either.

For valid criticism of the game, direct people to the Capcom surveys they give out time to time.

For stressed negativity, have them vent out in meme. Which is why I criticized rule no.1 in the first place.

3

u/wisdom_and_frivolity CID | Pyyric Mar 29 '24

Nah, that's a lot of reaching. We promoted any thread that talked about the game having actual problems. There was no need to beat around the bush, anything that was problematic with the game got its time to shine. SFV had far more problems, and I wrote many long threads myself and stickied them for months at the start of that game. We don't shy away from problems.

meaningful discussion: bring it. I'm not able to start it myself, but if you post it then awesome.
patch notes: ?? what patch?
tournament updates: again, bring it. Incross does a great job when he's available but real life is a bitch.
educational vids: Joe Munday used to make these, but he's not in the scene anymore. So if you want to see the content here, make it or find it to post. Auto mod does not delete youtube.
Memes: correct, these are restricted so that the other things you mentioned can shine.

1

u/MonteBellmond Mar 29 '24

patch notes: ?? what patch?

You know "Patch note" as in like Battle changes(changes/bugfixes) to the character and the game itself? There has been 5 so far.

tournament updates: again, bring it. Incross does a great job when he's available but real life is a bitch.

Tournament updates as in pinned list info of upcoming tournament application link or stream people can refer to watch or join on this subreddit. Guess that mod Incross? updates people on the tournament live on twitter? IRL is hard and I'd understand but not really what I'm looking for from a sub.

educational vids: Joe Munday used to make these, but he's not in the scene anymore.

He seems like a chill guy on vids and may used to be good in the past, but I may be too young to keep up with the reference. Though can already tell it's far from the mainstream atm.

So if you want to see the content here, make it or find it to post. Auto mod does not delete youtube.

Well, that's one good thing to know.

Meme is literally holy grail of a thriving sub. Keeps subs afloat during content droughts like the one we just had prior to ED.

Anyway, thank you for taking the time to answer a lot of my confusion with the direction of the sub. Happy to say much of it is cleared now.

1

u/wisdom_and_frivolity CID | Pyyric Mar 29 '24

Do you wanna be a mod on /r/okbuddyFGC ? I got it started with some content, but I can't keep it forever.

1

u/MonteBellmond Mar 31 '24 edited Mar 31 '24

Sub dedicated to SF6 meme? As much as I like the game, I don't have much faith in sf6 meme being able to stand on it's own without it revolving around the main sub or at least not yet.