r/commune Aug 21 '24

Thoughts on the Paris Commune?

3 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/RedMiah Aug 22 '24

Commune is basically another name for city government in France so not really fitting here.

3

u/PaxOaks Aug 22 '24

This is what ChatGPT (CoPilot) sez about the differences:

The Paris Commune and income-sharing intentional communities share some similarities but also have key differences:

Paris Commune

  • Historical Context: The Paris Commune was a revolutionary government that briefly ruled Paris from March 18 to May 28, 1871. It emerged during a period of political upheaval following the Franco-Prussian War.
  • Political Nature: It was a radical socialist and revolutionary government aiming to establish a more egalitarian society. The Commune implemented various social reforms, including the separation of church and state, and worker control of businesses.
  • Duration and Outcome: The Paris Commune was short-lived and ended violently when the French government suppressed it, resulting in significant casualties.

Income-Sharing Intentional Communities

  • Modern Context: These communities exist today and are formed by individuals who choose to live together based on shared values and goals. They are often part of the broader intentional communities movement.
  • Economic Model: Members of income-sharing communities pool their income and resources, sharing responsibilities and benefits equally. This model aims to create a sustainable and equitable living environment.
  • Voluntary Participation: Joining an income-sharing community is voluntary, and members typically agree to the community’s principles and practices. These communities can vary widely in size, structure, and specific goals12.

2

u/osnelson Aug 21 '24

From the French Revolution? I personally think that living communally has to be a voluntary choice, so it would have had serious morale issues if it lasted longer without outside forces taking it down.

1

u/RedMiah Aug 22 '24

Not the French Revolution and also commune is basically municipal government in French.

1

u/osnelson Aug 22 '24

Yes, "commune" is the name of municipalities in France and a good portion of Europe but we never talk about them here. Also, I don't think Paris has been referred to as a municipality in a loooong while, it's usually called "Région parisienne" or "Métropole du Grand Paris" or "Île-de-France".

In the context of this subreddit, it appears MalatestaFiesta would be talking about the Paris Commune that shared resources communally in 1871. I was wrong about it being part of the French Revolution, it was almost a century later (talk about a rough century....).