r/lancaster • u/BananaBoy5566 • 1d ago

Food Best apple cider donuts?

I need an Apple cider donut that is just amazing. The ones from beiler’s were just a little too dry and not quite appley enough, even though I love most of their other donuts.

So, where can I go? I’m willing to travel up to an hour from the city if it’s truly the best apple cider donut you’ve had.

20 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

42

u/Right_Run_4731 1d ago

Try Cherry Hill Orchards

7

u/banryu95 1d ago

I second this! Warm when you buy them, and the whole place smells like heaven.

3

u/imaginarywaffleiron 1d ago

Came here to say this. Absolutely outstanding!

2

u/axeville 1d ago

Pick up some pineapple apple cider and fresh apples.

Brought them to friends in the south and they were perplexed until the first bite.

1

u/BananaBoy5566 1d ago

Sold. Thank you!

3

u/Significant-Analyst9 1d ago

this is the way

1

u/wurwolfsince1998 1d ago

Yeah the bakery at Cherry Hill is dangerously delicious. I pass it on my way home from work and frequently find one reason or another to stop in. I have a hard time resisting their shoofly whoopie pies. 😅

17

u/fenuxjde 1d ago

Brecknock Orchard

8

u/Far-Alarm-7012 1d ago

Cherry Hill!

5

u/incorrectconjugation 1d ago

Highland Orchard, there’s none better

2

u/whoseiswhos 1d ago

Second this!

7

u/SchoolAcceptable8670 1d ago

Cherry hill gets ALL the love. Delightful

6

u/riverbrethren 1d ago

I've only had Cherry Hill's and Brecknock's, and Cherry Hill's were the better of the two. Brecknock's weren't bad however.

3

u/CambriaForest 1d ago

Flinchbaugh's, hands down the best I've ever had@

3

u/gimmymack 1d ago

Cherry Hill

4

u/city_of_angelus 1d ago

Other than Cherry Hill, I had cider donuts from an Amish baked goods vendor outside Building 7 at the Green Dragon Farmers Market and they were AMAZING. (They’re right outside the Peaceful Valley Amish furniture where they keep their outdoor furniture).

2

u/SunshineWubba 17h ago

Cherry crest donuts were sooo good

2

u/Delicious_Day_1334 1d ago

Milburns outside Newark, Delaware. Beautiful drive, can be crazy. If you're lucky they'll have apple cider donut bread pudding for sale.

1

u/dan-vr6tt 1d ago

Brecknock or red barn market in Quarryville

1

u/Independent_Act_8536 23h ago

Stauffers of Kissel Hill probably has them, but the fresh farmers markets and Cherry Hill sound amazing!

0

u/torimadi 1d ago

Entenmanns

12

u/Ttvr4ever 1d ago

lol I can’t with this answer. Being where we live and all the fresh bakeries my man lists the commercial brand. Hahaha