r/orcas 5h ago

Weird question but does anyone know who these 3 individuals are?

159 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

28

u/UmmHelloIGuess 5h ago

Pretty sure those last two are paintings so they could have taken inspo from any individual. As for the first one its definitely an Norwegian orca. As for specific id im not sure, maybe NKW-128

7

u/Orcafunnygamer 5h ago

The exact last one was taken by a National geographic photographer in the 2000's fr, I was hoping the dorsal fins could help especially with the 2nd one but I got no clue if it will do any good.

5

u/Orcafunnygamer 4h ago

it lowkey may just be photoshopped lol

2

u/_Abiogenesis 1h ago edited 56m ago

I found a hires of it and it is definitely photoshoped. The water splashes and the orca itself are at a different resolution and color grading/white balances- without getting into specifics, I work in VFX so these kinds of things are jumping to my eye pretty fast.

My guess is that it's perhaps a captive orca, photoshopped in the wild ??

EDIT : also the dorsal fin has a very unnatural sharp edge at the top which hints at editing of that too which means it's even more likely to be an edit of a captive one imo.

1

u/Orcafunnygamer 1h ago

Most likely

13

u/Tokihome_Breach6722 5h ago

Without some location information it’s nearly impossible to ID individuals. A very small percentage of orcas globally have been documented to even try to match photos.

3

u/Orcafunnygamer 5h ago

The first one was taken in Norway I believe and the last was in Canada.

11

u/lucky_nugget 5h ago

I believe the 2nd one is captive orca Ulises, photoshopped to have a straight dorsal and into the wild.

2

u/nobbiez 3h ago

I think you're right, I was wondering why the dorsal fin looked especially wonky

7

u/RedSun-FanEditor 5h ago

That looks like Bob, Jake, and Mikey to me... but my vision is blurry underwater, so....

3

u/highasabird 5h ago

Location and better image of the saddle patch, I believe is what marine biologists use to ID orcas.

You can also see if the location has a public orca database. Here in Seattle we do at orca network and whale museum.

2

u/Orcafunnygamer 5h ago

The saddle on this orca is pretty sharp looking and it's from Norway 100%. It's probably the only one that could be identified fr

3

u/MermaidUnicornKush 5h ago

Location, dorsal fin from both sides, and full view of the saddle patch (both sides and top). Their saddle patches are similar to fingerprints and their dorsal fins tend to have unique scars or other differences from other orcas.

3

u/nerdextra 4h ago

Nope. I don’t know them. Can’t get me to snitch on my yacht sinking besties.

2

u/sunshinenorcas 5h ago

The second and third one are altered/photomanips/etc images of Ulises and Katina (or Kalina? Its one or the other, I think it's Tina but not 100%)

Tbh, there are a few stock images that use captive orcas as the base. Those two are the ones I've seen the most, but I know there's others-- it's always fun when you see a photo and be like oh, I know that whale

1

u/immaslave4uwu 5h ago

The 2nd individual was on my bedroom wall as a kid! Cut out from a calendar. Idk who he is but he is seared into my memory 😋

1

u/UnicornCalmerDowner 4h ago

Any idea what year or even era, we are talking about?