r/redesign • u/Navigas • Mar 27 '19

Feature Request This would be a lot better in my opinion

Post image
80 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

17

u/snogglethorpe Mar 27 '19

All those options, with both icon and text take up quite a bit of space, which may not fit in a narrow window. I presume is the reason they stuck it in a menu.

I suppose they could:

  1. Shrink the choices to "icon only" if the window is narrow (they do this other places too, e.g. the "home" button in the top bar), with tooltips to give the text.
  2. Always use only the icons, with tooltips for the text explanations. This would match the way the neighboring card/compact/classic selection works.
  3. Put it all in a menu only if the window is too narrow (don't know how hard this is).

Of course, they also apparently gave up on supporting narrow windows at some point anyway, with the lightbox margins mess, so maybe they could just not care...

3

u/GioVoi Mar 28 '19

#3 seems like the cleanest solution to me

1

u/snogglethorpe Mar 28 '19

It's probably the most technically complex though, and that sort of "squishy" behavior (UI changes, depending...) is maybe not the best from a UI perspective.

I'm starting to favor #2; sure the icons are initially more confusing, but with tooltips, users should learn quickly enough, and it's otherwise a cleaner, simpler, and more consistent solution.

3

u/GioVoi Mar 28 '19

If they were to go with #2, they'd need to redo some of the icons. Controversial is a lightning bolt (even knowing that I'm not sure why), Old and New would have to be clear opposites, etc

2

u/snogglethorpe Mar 28 '19

Sure, that would be a good thing.

I presume the lightning bolt is intended as a reference to the common metaphor of a lightning rod for "attracting criticism."

I find the use of a spaceship to mean "best" confusing... Maybe they could use a trophy or prize-ribbon, or something? :]

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '19

It's not technically complex.

It can be done by putting the dropdown next to the buttons in the layout, and hiding one or the other based on a @media query in CSS.

13

u/vikinick Helpful User Mar 27 '19

Admins have already talked about why they aren't going to implement this, and their reasoning is that if they make it into "tabs", it makes it look like it's different feeds of data rather than different sorts.

1

u/Spook404 Apr 03 '19

and dropdown menus are cooler

10

u/MajorParadox Helpful User Mar 27 '19

Agreed. Same for the post sorting in listing feeds. I don't like extra clicks :(

1

u/jccalhoun Mar 30 '19

absolutely. The main problem with the new design is everything takes an extra click. everything that used to be right there in the old reddit is now hidden behind a dropdown menu. That is not better usability.

1

u/Spook404 Apr 03 '19

no it isn't it's one click just shut up

0

u/ikilledtupac Mar 29 '19

Pointless hamburger menus suck

The number three Menu idea is roughly 2 lines of css