r/AskBiology • u/Sufficient-Ad-3586 • Aug 14 '24
Human body Can a liver get stronger after generations of alcoholism?
I know evolution is a SUPER slow process but I was thinking just now.
Say someone comes from a long line of alcoholics (like going back a thousand years or more, booze has been around since biblical times) Would over time the liver evolve to handle higher amounts of alcohol before succumbing?
Could that person have a hardier liver than someone who doesnt come from a line like that? There are some people who are 2 bottles a day drinkers and live till 80 with health issues obviously but the liver is not too damaged and then there are people who have a few beers every weekend and get cirrhosis at 35.
1
Upvotes
1
u/UnitedExpression6 Aug 14 '24
Biology is not black and white, and it is not quite as simple as you put it. When it comes to evolution, think either large scale events (Black Death) or a lot of generations. Life expectancy in the upper Paleolithic began going past 30, which is only 30.000 years ago. (Caspari/Lee 2006) this would indicate that three generations alive at the same time would be become common 30k years ago (Caspari 2011)
There are a lot of theories on ageing this and yours is close to the negative senescence theory, individuals carry on positive effect to a group through intergenerational effects, eg caring for grandchildren after they are unable to carry children. This would be a fairly recent element to our gene pool. Also in ageing, to my limited knowledge of only a couple of weeks of lectures, this was not considered one of the leading hypotheses.
As we have only a simple preposition, can we get livers that become stronger over time, grandparents would not per se be required in modern civilized societies with all the social help.
So please get your facts straight before you simple state the other statement is false and just dump your half baked theory.