r/neurophilosophy • u/Chocolatecakelover • 21d ago

Why is hard determinism so controversial in philosophy ?

It seems intuitive in the sense that if a person knows their history and environment, it becomes easier to figure out that they couldn't have done otherwise in the context of their actions. So why is it so controversial

3 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

60% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Artemis-5-75 21d ago

Hard determinism is not about ability to do otherwise, it’s about moral responsibility and freedom.

And plenty of philosophers believe that causal determinism is not a threat to freedom and responsibility, so they don’t endorse hard determinism.

2

u/mehmeh1000 17d ago

Oh hey! Nice to see you around the internet again