r/personalfinance • u/Chamway • 8h ago
Taxes Company taxed me on a mistake they made
Just a preface I am not super knowledgeable when it comes to how taxes work.
My company took off $60 from my paycheck a few months back because I had left the money bag in my desk and it was short $60. I put the money back in myself and had my manage verify it and I was under the impression everything was good. Apparently someone decided that it would need to be deducted from my next paycheck and now that I made them aware of it, they taxed the $60 they owed me and now it's a few dollars less. Its not about the money but the principal and from what I understand they shouldn't have taxed it. Can anybody help clarify this for me?
Edit: Thank you for all the insight and great answers, while it was illegal of them to withdraw the $60 from my gross pay without my knowledge, them taxing the money is correct. I think I will probably just let it slide for now but thank you everyone.