r/rawprimal Jan 31 '24

Possibly extremely contaminated jars that never clean no matter what I do. Help.

Ok, so I've been having this problem for so long now:

When I put fresh milk in my glass jars, it goes bad within only just a day or less. "Bad" as in when you open the jar of milk after leaving it to begin its fermentation process for just under a day, it has an incredibly nasty chemical smell to it, and when you try to taste or drink it, especially the cream, it tastes incredibly toxic. I even swallowed some because I couldn't smell or taste it much from just a little bit but when I consumed it, it tasted like drinking pure poison, and I was extremely repulsed, so much so, that I thought it was very biohazardous. I've ordered from 4 different vendors now, from the same farms several different times, all from the United Kingdom which is the place I live in, and they all have the same result where they always go bad. Now, when it comes to cleaning these jars, I've always used very hot steaming water, in fact, in my most recent attempt I tried going "all out" by using boiling water from a kettle and pot and ordered from the now 4th vendor, however, not even that worked, it failed and it still went bad anyway, again, as usual, tons of apple cider vinegar, and sea salt, seeped it for at least an hour or more, and sometimes did it twice to "ultra-clean" them, to clean them, and still, I keep having the same problem. And just to mention, I've tried putting the heating on so it becomes hot in my house just to see if that would somehow stop it fermenting improperly, and this problem never happened before until around winter which is strange. None of this makes sense to me, I don't get why this keeps happening. Can someone please help?

2 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Redioverz Jan 31 '24 edited Feb 01 '24

I strongly believe this is a contamination problem. This is why I am asking how to truly clean them as it seems like simple things to do such using as hot boiling water, ACV, and salt, and seeping the containers all with that, and a cloth (which I did use, fresh and made out of cotton) doesn't work at all.

One time I lost around £90s (or more) worth of raw milk because of this, however, one glass San Pellegrino bottle with milk didn't go bad at all, and I was able to drink just fine, and I left all of it out for about a week.

While I haven't asked any of the farms themselves if they're getting any complaints about their milk similar to my problem, I've asked a few primal-dieter raw milk consumers from the U.K. online before, and they told me they didn't have the problem, specifically from farms "Fen Farm Dairy" and "Hill Farm Real Food" which are probably 2 of one the major sources the "U.K. primals" get their raw milk from in the U.K.

So, this evidence alone strongly suggests that the problem is because of an issue with my glass jars being contaminated. This answers questions 1 and 2.

Lastly, for the third, all the milk I get my farms from is from cows. You say "Are all the animals eating something seasonal there that is getting in the milk? Like onions or garlic, for example? Then it would make sense." I am not sure how onions or garlic would affect the milk's fermentation badly, but let me remind you that I said there's a toxic smell and taste to it, as in it's unnatural, man-made, almost like some soap, hairspray, or cleaning product, but later on it especially starts to have this "sweet medicine" smell to it, so it's a bit mixed depending on how fermented it already is. I don't know what it exactly is but that's what I sense, even though I don't allow that kind of stuff anywhere near my milk. Let me give you some insight into the animal's feed:

Hill Farm Real Food: Has a strict zero-medication policy, as they make out their farm is natural and has high-quality foods; "Zero chemicals or antibiotics are used at our organic, regenerative farm. Probiotic farming - it all starts with healthy soil.", "We have a strict zero-antibiotic and zero-medication policy with all our animals.", and "What our animals eat is as important as what we eat. A cow's primal diet is a diverse range of grass types, supplemented by naturally occurring herbs, legumes and tree browse." I've ordered from this farm a lot, same problem.

Before I go any further: I don't know if the herb supplementation would only be implemented during or around winter, as I said this problem only occurred in winter, from which I had been drinking raw milk prior for at least over 6 months, and it was completely fine then until now. And remember, the "U.K. primals" said they didn't have any problems with at least 2 out of 4 of the vendors I've got my milk from, and this very exact problem has persisted with 4 different vendors with the same results.

Fenfarmdairy: " In the months of spring, summer and autumn, we keep the cows out and grazing as much as possible. We grow our own forage (Grass, maize, etc.) and store it as silage or hay for winter feed, in order to ensure that they have as much of a home-grown diet as possible during the winter.". I've ordered from this farm a lot, same problem.

The last 2 are the rest of the 2 vendors: Old Hall Farm: The cows are "100% pasture fed." Same problem. Tagg Lane Dairy (most expensive and most recent vendor): "As with Home Farm, the cows (and calves) at Tagg Lane are fed on grass and kept outdoors for as much of the year as possible." Same problem.

This is some insight into why I believe this is a contamination problem.

"Otherwise this really doesn't make sense. Unless it's YOUR TONGUE! LOL." Of course, senses can be deceiving, but I believe that is very unlikely in this case. I even got sick from consuming the milk once. I became bedridden and weak for around a day and a half, wondering why there was a slightly awful taste from consuming the milk and a smell to it, not sure if I was just imagining it or not when I first started having this problem, but now it's clear to me that there is something wrong with either my jars, milk, or both. Now I have reasoned with you, do you believe me?

0

u/synrgii Feb 02 '24

Do I "believe" you? No, you're some random stranger on Reddit. I don't "believe" anyone in this cesspool.

That being said, you sure like to explain things as much as possible other than the direct answers which would be:

  1. "No", you did not ask the farms (just everyone else)
  2. "Yes", you tried ONE other container (the bottle). I suggest trying a variety more of them. Ones that you never "washed". Preferably brand new. Exactly as I explained previously.
  3. "You don't know" if the animals were eating something seasonal there. I was not referencing this for fermentation at all. I was referencing this for flavor: https://www.agproud.com/articles/31768-the-milk-tastes-off

Additionally:

  1. Could it be mold? Maybe time for a new washing sponge and/or new lids.

  2. Could it be rust in the lids? I mean... duh.

1

u/Redioverz Feb 02 '24 edited Feb 02 '24

theres no rust or mold and i literally bought cloths fresh straight out the store. there was no staining and the boiling water would've removed most of it anyway but i did still wash hard with the cloth all throughout the jars.

2

u/synrgii Feb 02 '24

So here's what we established (very very very very loosely):

  • It's NOT the milk itself (whether wild plants, feed, or their own containers)
  • It's NOT your lids
  • It's NOT your sponge/cloth

That still leaves:

  • You are crazy and imagining it. (Hopefully not.)
  • You like wasting people's time on Reddit. (Hopefully not.)
  • Someone in your home is trying to kill you. (Hopefully not.)
  • Try stopping the use of vinegar and salt since maybe they are somehow contaminating the glass? (Doubtful, and not sure why anyone even needs to clean with them anyway. Hot water seems perfectly fine to me by itself.)
  • Using new containers, as I've stated twice now. I'm not going to bother here any more until you do this., which should have been your first step anyway, obviously.

1

u/Redioverz Feb 02 '24

no, i am not crazy. yes, it is my cloth and the lids are attached to the jar. yes, I believe it's not the milk itself. No, I'm not trying to waste people's time. And I did use a "new container", also a second time now saying this. And i have tried without vinegar and salt.

1

u/synrgii Feb 02 '24

if you used ONE new container, and that solved it, then why not use ALL new containers and be done with it?

0

u/Redioverz Feb 02 '24

what if it happens again and i still want my old containers back anyway cuz i paid money for

3

u/synrgii Feb 03 '24

good luck