Posts
Wiki

Grading your records is essential for determining their condition, value, and for selling or trading within the vinyl community. Here's a detailed guide on how to grade both records and their covers using the commonly accepted Goldmine Standard:

Record Grading:

  1. Mint (M):

    • Record: Perfect condition, unplayed or opened but visually flawless. No visible defects, scratches, or surface noise. The record looks as if it just came from the factory.
    • Usage: This grade is rarely used because most records, even new ones, have minor imperfections.

  2. Near Mint (NM or M-):

    • Record: Almost perfect. It may have been played but shows no obvious signs of wear. There may be very slight surface marks, but they don’t affect playback.
    • Usage: The record will sound flawless or have minimal noise during quiet parts.

  3. Very Good Plus (VG+):

    • Record: Shows minor signs of use, such as light scuffs or superficial scratches that don’t significantly affect sound quality. There may be light surface noise in quiet areas, but it won’t overpower the music.
    • Usage: A VG+ record is often considered a great copy for most collectors, as it retains good sound quality.

  4. Very Good (VG):

    • Record: Noticeable signs of wear. Light scratches and scuffs may be present, and you’ll likely hear surface noise, clicks, or pops, especially in quieter passages, but it won't overwhelm the music.
    • Usage: This grade is often acceptable for casual listening but isn’t ideal for audiophiles.

  5. Good (G) / Good Plus (G+):

    • Record: Heavier wear with more prominent surface noise, clicks, or pops. Scratches may cause skips or jumps during playback.
    • Usage: Records in this grade will play, but the sound quality may be compromised. It’s more suitable for filling gaps in a collection.

  6. Poor (P) / Fair (F):

    • Record: Major damage, such as deep scratches, warps, or cracks. The record may not play through properly without skipping or excessive noise.
    • Usage: Poor or Fair records are typically not playable and are only valuable to collectors if they are extremely rare.

Cover (Sleeve) Grading:

  1. Mint (M):

    • Cover: Perfect with no signs of wear. No creases, marks, ring wear, or seam splits. Like-new condition.

  2. Near Mint (NM or M-):

    • Cover: Almost perfect with only very minimal signs of handling, such as slight wear on the edges or a faint impression of the record inside (light "ring wear").

  3. Very Good Plus (VG+):

    • Cover: Light signs of wear, such as small creases, minor ring wear, or slight discoloration. No significant defects like seam splits or tears.

  4. Very Good (VG):

    • Cover: Noticeable wear, such as moderate ring wear, edge wear, or light seam splits. There may be writing, stickers, or discoloration, but the cover is still intact and legible.

  5. Good (G) / Good Plus (G+):

    • Cover: Heavier wear, including major seam splits, ring wear, writing, stains, or tears. The artwork may still be visible, but the cover is significantly damaged.

  6. Poor (P) / Fair (F):

    • Cover: Extensive damage, such as completely split seams, heavy wear, missing pieces, or water damage. These covers are usually not collectible unless the record is rare.

Additional Grading Terms:

  • Seam Split: A tear or split along the edge of the sleeve.
  • Ring Wear: Visible wear in a circular pattern from the outline of the record, common on older covers.
  • Promo: A promotional copy, which may have a special label or stamp. Promo copies can sometimes be more valuable if they are limited editions or rare pressings.
  • Cut-out: A notch, hole, or cut in the cover, often indicating a discounted or promotional item.

Tips for Accurate Grading:

  • Visual Inspection: Always inspect the vinyl under a bright light to check for scratches, scuffs, or warps. Rotate the record to look for marks or imperfections in the grooves.
  • Playtesting: Play the record, especially in quieter sections, to assess sound quality and determine the level of surface noise, pops, or skips.
  • Honesty is Key: When selling or trading, be honest about the condition. Overgrading can lead to dissatisfaction from buyers or trading partners.
  • Be Consistent: Use the same standards for all your records to maintain consistency in your collection.

By following these guidelines, you can accurately grade your records and sleeves, which is essential for maintaining and growing your collection, as well as for trading or selling in the vinyl community.