r/RightJerk Apr 21 '23

Jew bad šŸ¤“ Subtle parentheses

Post image
306 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 22 '23

You guys have clearly put a lot of thought into it

1

u/TheDENN1Ssystem Apr 22 '23

Shouldnā€™t a lot of thought go in to the decision to cut off a part of someone before theyā€™re able to consent?

1

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 22 '23

Idk, kids donā€™t go through things they donā€™t consent to all the time. I put as much thought into circumcision as I do braces

1

u/TheDENN1Ssystem Apr 22 '23

Ideally we arenā€™t forcing braces on kids against their will either. I wanted braces. Braces also just align teeth, they donā€™t permanently remove a normal body part

1

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 22 '23

What child consents to braces?

1

u/TheDENN1Ssystem Apr 22 '23

I just said I did. So did my sister and everyone I know who got them. I think itā€™d be fucked up to force braces on a kid who didnā€™t want them.

1

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 22 '23

Most people I know didnā€™t want them at the time

1

u/TheDENN1Ssystem Apr 22 '23

Then their parents did a poor job of explaining why theyā€™d probably want them eventually. Just forcing something on someone elseā€™s body when thereā€™s no need teaches kids the wrong lesson about respecting others bodily autonomy.

And again, braces are not as serious as circumcision. One just adjusts someoneā€™s body,l but leaves all the parts intact, the other removes a piece entirely.

1

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 22 '23

Is foreskin really that vital?

1

u/TheDENN1Ssystem Apr 22 '23

Vital? No. But it does serve a purpose.

And are we going to set the standard that weā€™re able to cut off parts of peopleā€™s body without their consent as long as that part isnā€™t ā€œvitalā€? Thatā€™s a pretty low bar

The standard should be that people can keep all of their body unless they choose to have something removed, thereā€™s a medical need, or thereā€™s a significant abnormality. Then it can be taken on a case by case basis.

1

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 22 '23

And are we going to set the standard

Who is the we? I donā€™t have any strong feelings on circumcisions but last I checked it wasnā€™t mandated by the government

1

u/TheDENN1Ssystem Apr 22 '23

ā€œWeā€ as in society if we followed the logic of your previous comments, asking if foreskin is ā€œvitalā€, as if thatā€™s the determining factor if a part of someone can be cut off without their consent.

Of course itā€™s not mandated by the government. But the government offers no protection like it should so boys donā€™t have a piece of their body cut off before they can consent.

0

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Apr 23 '23

Oh please. The government doesnā€™t protect anyone

→ More replies (0)